anchor link to jump to start of content

The Seattle Times Company NWclassifieds NWsource seattletimes.com

space
NEXT home page
Letters to NEXT
NEXTopia Weblog
Polls
Speak out
Meet the NEXT team
space
space
NEXTopia

Welcome to NEXTopia, a Web diary in which NEXT writers — and readers — share their evolving thoughts on a variety of issues. The opinions you read below are those of the individual writers, not necessarily those representing The Seattle Times.
Respond to NEXTopia
Currently, NEXTopia cannot automatically post readers' comments on the blog. However, writers and editors will regularly post your name and comments unless you note otherwise.

space space space space
Meet NEXT
Our freelance team and advisory board members who contribute to this blog.

Photo of Christina Asavareungchai
Christina Asavareungchai
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Sharon Altaras
Sharon Altaras
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Drew Avery
Drew Avery
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Althea Cawley-Murphree
Althea Cawley-Murphree
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Camille Coldeen
Camille Coldeen
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Chris Collins
Chris Collins
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Dana Dibble
Dana Dibble
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Karan Gill
Karan Gill
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Randy Henderson
Randy Henderson
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Gavin Hesse
Gavin Hesse
E-mail | Bio

Photo of John Hieger
John Hieger
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Hana Kawai
Hana Kawai
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Anne Kim
Anne Kim
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Kailani Koenig-Muenster
Kailani Koenig-Muenster
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Brent Ludeman
Brent Ludeman
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Nate Robinson
Nate Robinson
E-mail | Bio

Photo of April Seipp
April Seipp
E-mail | Bio

Photo of W. John Schroder
W. John Schroder
E-mail | Bio

Photo of Daniel Thies
Daniel Thies
E-mail | Bio


Colleen Pohlig
E-mail | Bio

Robert Hernandez
E-mail | Bio

Tracy Cutchlow
E-mail | Bio

Eric Devericks
E-mail | Bio

James Blethen
E-mail | Bio

Boo Davis
E-mail | Bio

Carlin Pressnall
E-mail | Bio

space
November 24, 2004

Unprincipaled recount mania

Q: What makes it so easy to become disenchanted with politics and assume that all politicians are playing the "public servant" game just for a power rush?

A: The fact that political bosses and politicians so routinely push an agenda in the name of upholding an unbending principle that, in reality, is subject to change at a moment's notice.

Case in point: The Washington state Republican and Democratic parties are asking for every vote to be legitimately counted in the governor's race (Democratic party chairman Paul Berendt: the governor must be "elected legally and legitimately, and with a majority of the votes.").

So that means a second recount if necessary -- or, rather, only if their candidate is trailing after the first recount.

Berendt says Democrats will likely ask for a second recount presumably because there are "so many (recount) anomalies across the state," he told The Seattle Times. As a principle, the governor should be elected "legally and legitimately."

That sounds fair enough. Berendt is for democracy and voter rights, right?

But his principles, it turns out, are only based on scenarios: If Gregoire is behind after the first recount, the Dems will call for a recount on the recount. If Gregoire happens to take the lead after the first recount, then the rules change: "Obviously, if we're ahead, we won't be asking for a recount. The experts tell me that's a standard rule," Berendt said.

The experts tell Berendt that's a standard rule? I guess expert advice trump principles.

Now let's look at state Republican party chairman Chris Vance's principles. If Gregoire loses in the recount, she "do the decent thing, the honorable thing, and concede the election." That means no second recount.

But... Vance is not ruling out the possibility that the Republicans may call for a second recount if Rossi trails after the first recount. Besides, Vance says, Rossi is in a "fundamentally different position" than Gregoire because he won the initial count.

Explain how Rossi is in such a fundamentally different position that Vance's principle of letting the recount stand and not dragging out the election only applies only to Gregoire and not Rossi? The phrase "double standard" comes to mind.

It's hard to trust politicians who appeal to "decency" and voter rights as reasons for their agendas when these principles can be easily overruled by expert advice or who happens to win the next recount.

Respond to Chris

 
Posted by Chris Collins at November 24, 2004 03:01 PM


 November 2004
S M T W T F S
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30        

 ARCHIVES
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003

 RECENT ENTRIES
The other white meat government
Turkey expert
Recount hypocrisy
Unprincipaled recount mania
Can't wait for the statue
Infamous brawl
No more money worries
What happened?
The two Nates
Governor's race

 LINKS

Other blogs to watch

Liberal

Talking points memo
Altercation, by Eric Alterman (MSNBC.com)
Daily Kos - Political Analyst
Cursor
The American Prospect - Tapped
Whiskey Bar
Counterspin Central
The War in Context
Between the Lines

Conservative

The Belgravia Dispatch (London conservatism)
Real Clear Politics
Anne Coulter
The Right Coast
National Review Online
The Daily Dish - Andrew Sullivan
Banana Republican
ScrappleFace

Other

Antiwar.com
Reason online - Hit and Run
Juan Cole - Informed Comment
Calpundit
DaveBARRY.com
Think About It

Local

Stefan Sharkansky's Shark Blog
Seattle Sucks
Tikun Olam
Afterthoughts

Entertainment

Pop Culture Junk Mail (local pop culture)
Three Imaginary Girls (local indie-pop music)
MISCmedia.com (local)
MOBYlives (literary critique)
Blogcritics.org (everything pop culture)


Powered by
Movable Type 2.51


SUNDAYS IN THE PAPER, ALL THE TIME ONLINE
line
Speak out: NEXT welcomes letters and opinion submissions
More opinion from The Seattle Times

seattletimes.com home
Home delivery | Contact us | Search archive | Site map | Low-graphic
NWclassifieds | NWsource | Advertising info | The Seattle Times Company

Copyright

Back to topBack to top