Mariners Blog
Geoff Baker covers the Mariners for The Seattle Times. He provides daily coverage of the team throughout spring training, and during the season.
December 12, 2007 4:58 PM
The Mitchell Report's forgotten names
Posted by Geoff Baker
Only 18 more hours to go until the Mitchell Report is released by MLB and adds roughly 60 to 80 names to the growing list of baseball players said to have used performance enhancing drugs. I know this report will be greeted by plenty of skepticism. I know there are those out there who say the past should be kept in the past and that many of the ballplayers will have used the drugs before they were outlawed by MLB.
But I think it's an important story that needs to be followed up on. In all of its complexities. Fingers need to be pointed not just at the players who took drugs to further their careers. But also at the teams, players' union and MLB leadership that largely turned a blind eye to the problem. One thing that won't surprise me about the list of names tomorrow is if it contains an abnormally high percentage of Latin Americans.
Latin America and the involvement of its players with steroids is a subject I've followed with great interest for the past three years. I travelled to the Dominican Republic in 2005 for the Toronto Star and did an extensive, two-part investigative report about how steroids and other performance enhancing drugs (like farm supplements meant for large animals) were easily obtained and frequently used by teenagers there.
An excellent photo essay on those stories, taken by photographer Peter Power, who accompanied me throughout the trip, can be viewed by clicking on this link. The text link on the Zuma Press page also contains Part II of my series. That story was about the so-called "buscones" -- unlicensed street agents who gather up all the young ballplayers they can find on the streets of the Dominican and "groom" them to become professionals as young as age 16. How are these prospects groomed? Well, for one thing, major league teams scouring for talent at that age will want to see young players who physically show them something.
How does a great young player gain physical maturity by age 16 or 17? Well, some are truly gifted, freaks of nature. Others get help from a needle. Even the truly gifted ones get a needle boost at times. Injections are nothing to young Dominican boys, who start taking vitamin B-12 shots given by their teams and "buscones" at ages as young as 11 or 12. Mix some performance enhancing drugs into those shots and well, the vitamin "boost" becomes bigger.
How did Rafael Palmeiro say he wound up with the anabolic steroid stanozolol in his system? Why, from a B-12 shot given him by then-Baltimore teammate Miguel Tejada, subject of today's big swap with the Astros. Yeah, still taking B-12 shots in the majors. Some habits die hard.
That's kind of my point. You can pass all the rules you like, provide education to players about the harm such drugs can do to their system, but the bottom line is: old habits are hard to break. When you've been groomed on steroids or farm animal supplements from even before you're a teenager, it's going to be psychologically difficult to break your dependence -- even if it's only a mental one -- on such performance enhancers. Ballplayers are a very superstitious, highly-regimented bunch. The Dominican ballplayer who escaped a horrible life of poverty by hitting a baseball further than anyone else is going to be reluctant to stop taking enhancers if that's something he's been doing all of his life.
Take a look at the photos from Peter Power and you'll see one of a scrawny ballplayer and his mother standing outside their shantytown home (my hand is on the far right, holding a pen). That boy was actually a 17-year-old, who looks about 13 because, I'm told, of malnourishment. But he dreamed of following his hero, David Ortiz, into the major leagues. He knew he had to get bigger if his hitting ability (said to be pretty good) was going to attract attention. I don't know what happened to the boy. Don't know whether he just filled-out naturally, started pumping weights, or if he's still even playing ball. But I do know that the boys all around him were all doing what they had to in order to get bigger. What would you do if you were him?
I mention this boy because I saw Ortiz quoted in a Boston Herald story from this year saying that for all he knows, he may have taken steroids back when he was in the Dominican. Hey, it's entirely possible. That's how rampant the problem is down there. Nothing would surprise me. Some groups, like the New York-based Hispanics Across America, have called on MLB to institute drug testing for baseball prospects in the Dominican and Venezuela before they sign pro contracts.
MLB has balked at doing it. Part of the problem is money, since this would be a very costly venture. The other part is legal, since none of these prospects are actually employees of any MLB team. You're talking about a U.S.-based corporate entity extending its rules on to foreign soil.
MLB has already stepped on some toes and waded through legal murk by extending its drug testing policy to the Dominican and Venezuelan Summer Leagues. Venezuelan players in that league (under contract to MLB teams) receive the full brunt of the plan and the same penalities if caught, as I reported on a year ago for the Times when I visited Venezuela. As you can see by reading, the plan has run into its share of problems while being implemented. But the fact Venezuelan pros are now being tested and punished is a huge step forward from where MLB was just three years ago.
The photos below are a couple I took of batting practice being taken by a Venezuelan Winter League "B" team. The guy throwing it is a Pittsburgh Pirates prospect who has to work out with this club because he's been suspended 50 games from any Venezuelan Summer League activity after getting caught with steroids in his system.


The punishments are not the same in the Dominican Republic. Violators of MLB's drug policy there cannot be suspended, mainly because Dominican labor law won't allow players to be denied employment for taking drugs that are actually legal in that country.
So, it's an enforcement program with no teeth.
As you can see, it's a challenge just to test and punish the pros. But the reality is, most of these players being caught got their start on performance enhancing drugs well before they turned pro. By the time they reach the pro ranks, their dependence -- mental and physical -- on these drugs to achieve athletic success is ingrained. Some of them are taking human growth hormone, or animal supplements, which are not being tested for.
This isn't as simple as saying that kids in California, or Florida, face the same pressures. Or an unfair obstacle in competing for jobs against Dominican and Venezuelans being groomed as "pros" -- drugs, training and all -- from their pre-teen years onwards. Baseball in the Dominican and -- to some extent -- Venezuela truly is a life-or-death thing. For those who don't make the big leagues (and we're talking about 95 percent of those signed as "pros" for bonuses usually totalling $5,000 to $15,000), they have little education and will be doomed to a grim future. Many of them took their drugs, got bigger, gave up school and were told baseball would cure everything in their lives. They were told wrong and were largely forgotten about once dropped by their teams. But at least they have their bonuses. The ballplayers who don't get signed wind up doing untold damage to themselves for nothing.
Whatever happens tomorrow, this is a sad story we're talking about. Try not to think only about the names of major leaguers that get mentioned. Think of this problem in the context of all those names you'll never get to hear about -- shining shoes or living in a tin shack in some impovershed neighborhood. Steroids and the pressure to take them is only part of the global exploitation of players from underdeveloped countries.
But it's an important part.
I don't bat an eyelash when I hear that a Dominican player like Jose Guillen, who I had many casual conversations about steroids with during his time in Seattle, has been linked in news reports to performance enhancing drugs. It disappoints me. But it doesn't surprise me.
And a part of me, based on what my eyes have seen, feels greater empathy for Latin American born players named in such drug stories. Far greater than I have for their American and Canadian counterparts. Much more than I have for the product of a wealthy family and school system like Barry Bonds. Yes, it's a double-standard and you don't have to agree with it.
But it's two different worlds we're talking about. And they're about to come together tomorrow.
Posted by Tim
6:25 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Geoff,
It's when you write something like this or your 9/11 post that I really realize how lucky we are to have a writer of your excellent abilities writing in Seattle.
Thanks,
Tim
Posted by Clay Aiken
6:33 PM, Dec 12, 2007
http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=3151913
Thats a recent article on ESPN about Kuroda... made me feel better!!
Posted by Resin isn't Cheating
6:57 PM, Dec 12, 2007
One thing that won't surprise me about the list of names tomorrow is if it contains an abnormally high percentage of Latin Americans.
Not to diminish your excellent research and personal knowledge of Latin American players, but the fact remains the majority of today's players are Latino. So simplified, of course one can point out to any category and you will always have more Latinos lead in that category because they are the majority ethnicity represented today. I believe it's unfair to categorize the "Selig Steroid Era" with young teenagers willing to do anything in the Domican Republic and Venezuela to escape poverty by seeking out buscones. I believe it's a complete seperate issue with steroid use today. Today's players that are cheaters do so willingly. I believe "National Origin" has nothing to do with the players that will be revealed in the Mitchell report. Here are the following NON-LATINOS who have been linked to performance enhancing drugs; Jamal Strong, Mike Morse, Matt Lawton, Mike Cameron, Mark Mcguire, Barry Bonds, Jay Gibbons, Paul Byrd, Scott Schoenweis, Gary Matthews Jr., Jason Grimsley, Jerrt Hairston Jr., Troy Glaus, Rick Ankiel, Ryan Franklin, Matt Williams, Termel Sledge, Drek Turnbow, Lenny Dykstra, Andy Pettite, Roger Clemens, David Bell, Darren Holmes, Bryan Roberts, Dave Hollins, John Rocker, Wally Joiner,Jim Leyritz, Ken Camimiti, Jason Giambi.
Posted by Merrill
7:03 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Thanks, Geoff. Heavy stuff, and complex. I agree with Tim.
Posted by Drew V.
7:15 PM, Dec 12, 2007
I agree Geoff. In a way I feel bad for the Latino guys being named. It's two different worlds and they are being thrown into ours at such a young age.
Posted by Kyle in Kentucky
7:55 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Great thoughts as usual Geoff. In other news, Mark Prior is now a free agent. I think he'd be worth a flier by the Ms. He's out for half of next year...but he still has talent. Can't be any more risky than any other move we've pulled off lately.
Posted by ricofoy
8:12 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Maybe their reluctance to stop taking enhancers is because they really do help. Ya think?
We're not talking about 15 year old kids here, we're talking about grown men, in the majors, who knew that what they were doing was cheating and in many cases illegal.
I don't feel sorry for any of them, not a single one. I feel sorry for the prospect who has been toiling in the minors for a dozen years because he wasn't quite good enough and didn't resort to cheating to achieve his dream.
But really what difference does it make? We all know drug cheat Jose Guillen is in the report and he just signed a $36 million contract. Tomorrow they'll be a smattering of outrage but mostly a collective shrug and that'll be that.
Posted by oregongal
8:51 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Thanks for the perspective, Geoff. The whole steroid issue is tragic and there's no good solution at this point.
Posted by Kyle in Kentucky
8:52 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Eight minutes 'til we have to tender a contract to Ramirez and Broussard. Anyone hear anything? I haven't seen anything yet. We'll see what happens...
Posted by Harmony
9:15 PM, Dec 12, 2007
I hope this information can find a broader audience than your blog offers.
Great work.
Posted by wayupwaydown
9:44 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Geoff,
Your insight into this is about 10 steps above anything else I have ever read on the subject.
It seems that in many issues the more one learns, the more confusing it gets. Thanks for providing some balance and making me think a little deeper about this issue.
Posted by scrapiron
9:57 PM, Dec 12, 2007
The Mariners just traded Ben Broussard to the Texas Rangers for Tug Hulett. Tug Hullett?!
Why couldn't the Mariners offer arbitration to Broussard, then after he signs trade him for more than Tug Hulett? I know there is the risk of getting "stuck" with a player you don't want, but I don't think Broussard was a player that couldn't contribute to the Mariners, no matter what the cost. I guess I don't understand the whole non-tender process. Could someone enlighten me?
Posted by Henderballs
11:53 PM, Dec 12, 2007
"Part of the problem is money, since this would be a very costly venture. The other part is legal, since none of these prospects are actually employees of any MLB team. You're talking about a U.S.-based corporate entity extending its rules on to foreign soil."
Is MLB completely devoid of common sense? It doesn't have to push laws on other countries, or spend money-- how about a rule that any players upon signing have to take a drug test before they can become employees? I've had to. If they fail, they can't sign for a set amount of time, or better yet, they'd be SOL forever like me if I failed a drug test.
Unfortunately the player's union has a policy against steroid testing and anything that comes close to incentive as a form of policy, and the owners don't have the spine to do what's right.
Posted by jwb
3:13 AM, Dec 13, 2007
Henderballs,
"Unfortunately the player's union has a policy against steroid testing. . ."
First, that is not true, but not really relevant to your point. Second, the players' union represents only players with MLB contracts and has nothing to do with the testing of players not on 40 man rosters. Direct your ire on this issue towards MLB.
"If they fail, they can't sign for a set amount of time, or better yet, they'd be SOL forever like me if I failed a drug test."
The situation is different. Let's say you are a rocket scientist. If you fail a drug test while applying for a job at NASA, you have other employment options such as Martin/Lockheed, Grumman/Northrup, Boeing, Comcast, Hughes, and various other US satellite companies. And that's just in the US. You may not want to take a job in another country, but there jobs in other countries. MLB is the only employer in the US. There are a very small number of baseball jobs available in Japan, Korea, and in US indy leagues, but none of these ar geared geared towards training teenagers to become professional ballplayers.
Posted by Chris Dahl
5:58 AM, Dec 13, 2007
Geoff,
Nicely done. You know, it's nice to read an enlightened perspective once in a while. Thanks for sharing your insight and getting past the salacious garbage that passes for news in other publications.
Posted by Henderballs
8:15 AM, Dec 13, 2007
JWB-- excellent points. I do think that the player's union has demonstrated, if not a policy, then a stance against drug testing in the past. I would be suprised if they would not oppose testing a condition of hire.
Regardless if its the union or MLB, the best thing they can do for those kids is to take the incentive for doing the drugs away, and the only way I can think to do it is through testing as a condition for hire.
Posted by -k
9:36 AM, Dec 13, 2007
Absolutely excellent reporting! We in Seattle are lucky to have you writing for our Times.
Jul 4, 08 - 03:16 PM
Detroit Tigers at Mariners: 07/04 game thread
Jul 4, 08 - 12:28 PM
Holiday optimism
Jul 3, 08 - 11:13 PM
Better opposition tonight
Jul 3, 08 - 08:56 PM
Detroit Tigers at Mariners: 07/03 game thread
Jul 3, 08 - 05:45 PM
Hernandez throws, Rowland-Smith blogs, Clement struggles

nwautos
Associated Press Study: Fatal crashes down in Washington Last year Washington's roads were the scene of the fewest fatal crashes since 1955. According...
Post a comment
nwjobs
Post a comment
Michelle Goodman blogs about work/life balance.
Five reasons to stick with a job you hate -- for now
Post a comment

- Steve Kelley | My treatment of Bedard has been unfair
- Is Washington's tax exemption on bullion a gold mine?
- 747-8 soars smoothly on first outing
- Super Bowl ads: Betty White, Bud Light, big laughs
- Man found shot dead in pickup truck in Seattle
- Sex, drug rumors swirl about N.Y. Gov. Paterson
- Alaska Air dropping Jones Soda beverages, going back to Coca-Cola
- Lewis-McChord soldier charged with abusing 4-year-old over alphabet lesson
- Seattle is first U.S. stop for Picasso exhibit
- Husky Football Blog | Pac-10 expansion to get consideration over next year
- Seattle is first U.S. stop for Picasso exhibit
- 747-8 soars smoothly on first outing
- City, Vulcan push higher South Lake Union height limits
- Commentary: Microsoft's creative destruction
- Snap out of your photo funk: How to make sense of all those piles of images
- Belltown boulevard could be completed by early next year
- Wine Adviser | Oregon's quality pinots join the bargain ranks
- All You Can Eat | Portage chef Vuong Loc takes Cremant space in Madrona
- Jerry Large | Learning not to copy China
- Rigorous college-prep classes skyrocketing in Washington state








Posted by Maui Mariner
6:14 PM, Dec 12, 2007
Well that's quite an insight into the seedy underbelly of major league baseball..............
Thanks for the input Geoff