Husky Football Blog
Times reporter Bob Condotta keeps the news coming about the Montlake Dawgs.
September 6, 2008 10:53 PM
Posted by Bob Condotta
On what was kind of a slow day in college football, the penalty called against Jake Locker is emerging as maybe the most-discussed occurrence of the weekend.
Here's a look at some of the reaction:
--- ESPN's Ted Miller says it was a terrible call that "may irrevocably doom'' Tyrone Willingham at UW. There will be plenty of time to debate that later, but the math is obvious --- UW needs to win six of its last 10 games just to get to 6-6 and has Oklahoma, USC, Arizona State and Cal all remaining on the schedule, among others.
--- A fannation.com blogger calls the official "overzealous'' and points out the BCS implications of the penalty.
--- Matthew Zemek of Fox Sports says that fans will now remember the game for all the wrong reasons, making the point that it could hurt BYU a little that all people will recall of this one is what happened at the end.
--- Jay Drew of the Salt Lake Tribune says the call was a definite break for BYU but to say that it altered the outcome of the game is "a stretch.''
--- Jeff Call of the Deseret News in Salt Lake says it's a bad rule, but that reading the rule, it was the right call, which I think is pretty much the stance of Willingham. Also in that link is a post from Deseret News columnist Dick Harmon who says BYU should have won by 7-14 points.
For those curious, UW officials say they won't be filing a protest. Since the rule is in the book and the call is an enforcement of the rule, there's really nothing to file a protest about. Also, the reality is there's nothing tangible that could come of it since obviously, they won't replay the end of the game.
My take? I agree it was a bad call, and to say that there's no judgment involved doesn't make sense. Isn't there judgment on any call? I think they could have used some better judgment there. And while I guess it's not really something the refs can or would do, the fact that the person involved is Locker, who I think everyone can agree is as classy a player and person as there is, seems like something that in an ideal world would be taken into account.
But you can't ignore that UW still had a chance to tie the game with what is a fairly routine kick --- Ryan Perkins made a 35-yarder last week at Oregon with ease. And you also have to remember that would have merely tied it --- UW still would have had to win the game in overtime when it hadn't really stopped BYU since the second half.
And if you look at the numbers --- BYU's 475 yards to UW's 337, for instance --- it's hard to argue that the Cougars didn't deserve to win. That said, overtime sure would have been fun, which may be the biggest tragedy of the whole thing.
Furniture & home furnishings
Adjustable Bed Unused, w/massage, queen, 8 ...
AKC Rare Red Parti Standard Poodle Pups
Beautiful AKC Bullmastiff Puppies
POST A FREE LISTING