Advertising

The Seattle Times Company

NWjobs | NWautos | NWhomes | NWsource | Free Classifieds | seattletimes.com

Editorials / Opinion


Our network sites seattletimes.com | Advanced

Ed cetera

Join the informed, opinionated journalists of The Times' editorial staff in lively discussions at our blog Ed Cetera.

About the contributors| RSS feeds Subscribe | Blog Home

June 11, 2008 3:35 PM

When is a GOP member a Republican?

Posted by Kate Riley

Oh, horrors! Stop the presses. Republican gubernatorial candidate Dino Rossi is trying to "rebrand" himself as a member of the Grand Old Party. How sinister.

The real horror here is the state Democratic party's attempt, in a press release today, to invent a scandal out of nothing -- and, worse, the premise for their argument is founded on an apparent belief that voters are too ignorant to know that "GOP" and "Republican" are the same thing -- or that they will live in a cave between now and the general election, missing what will likely be another tortuous high-profile campaign where each candidate is thoroughly dissected.

Worse yet, party officials are using their breathless, outraged press release to hide their own duplicitousness. This looks like just another of the Democratic party's efforts to undermine the state's new top-two primary and get it overturned. Again.

Fact is, Rossi was among 22 candidates filing for state and local offices who stated their party preference as "GOP." About another 120 stated their preference was "Republican." My colleague David Postman discusses the issue here.

Here's the state Democratic party's press release in part.

Dems call on Rossi to stop trying to deceive Washingtonians

If Rossi won’t be transparent voluntarily, Sam Reed should force his hand

SEATTLE - Washington State Democratic Party Chairman Dwight Pelz today called on Republican Dino Rossi to voluntarily amend his ballot choice from the confusing, deceptive, and redundant “Prefers G.O.P. Party” to his true party label - Republican. Rossi has until 5pm today to alter his ballot listing, which appears to be a “re-branding” effort he’s undertaken to avoid discussing that he’s a Republican in the mold of George W. Bush. (Does it stand for “George’s Old Policies”???)

Republican Sam Reed has said he disapproves of Rossi’s scheme, and Rossi is the only statewide candidate in the Republican Party to employ this deceptive tactic. Reed has cautioned against “funny business” on the ballot, but his responsibility as the top elections official in Washington state obliges him to put the power of his office behind enforcing his rhetoric.

The release goes on to cite the Wall Street Journal's decision to stop using "GOP" in 2002. But they neglect to mention that both Seattle newspapers continue to use "Republican" and "GOP" interchangeably.

First of all -- and this is no news flash -- under the new Top Two Primary, it doesn't matter one whit what your party is. Washington has a qualifying primary now, which means the top two vote-getters advance to the general election, no matter what their party preference. This is the voters' primary -- no longer the party's nominating primary.

Second -- under the new primary, candidates can describe their party preference in any socially appropriate way as long as its within 15 characters. In fact, attorneys defending the top-two primary in court argued candidates would be exercising their First Amendment rights by stating their preference.

Third -- By the time November rolls around, voters no doubt will be well grounded in the differences between Dino Rossi and the incumbent Gov. Chris Gregoire. By then, they will probably want to go hide in a cave.

The state parties for the Democrats, Libertarians and Republicans want the new top two primary overturned because it takes them out of the voting equation. Too bad. They successfully sued to overturn Washington's popular blanket primary because it did not afford the parties enough control over which candidates got on the general election ballot. Voters revolted when they were forced to have a partisan primary and embraced the top-two primary, and the U.S. Supreme Court, 7-2, sided with the voters -- against the parties. And none other than Chief Justice John G. Roberts wrote a concurring opinion with suggestions for how to do it without running afoul of the law.

But the parties are back in court trying to overturn the new primary on other grounds. And they are doing whatever they can to prove voters are confused by the new primary to give them more grounds to overturn it.

Voters are smarter than Democratic officials are giving them credit for. After all, voters approved the top-two primary, didn't they?

Digg Digg | Newsvine Newsvine

Submit a comment

*Required Field



Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Posted by michael

2:46 PM, Jun 12, 2008

Kate, relax and take a breath. It's only a hullabaloo if the media choose to bite and turn it into one.

Posted by Don B. Sea

2:59 PM, Jun 12, 2008

Kate, Kate, Kate. It's not so much that people do or do not know that Republican and GOP are used for the smae thing in articles, etc., but the attempt of these assorted individuales to HIDE from the word Republican on their posters, flyers, etc., that is the issue. Sneaky as ever. If you are a Republican, have the guts to stand up and have that work plastered proudly on all of your forms, papers, etc. If not, don't run for any office. Sit home and let others wth some guts try running this year with Republican attached to their good name. Ha!

Posted by Kate Riley

3:22 PM, Jun 12, 2008

Michael, Thanks for your comment.
Guilty. Though I was "biting" on the media hullabaloo, not the invented scandal.
The beauty of the top two is that it deliberately makes party affiliation so much less important. This silly exercise of lining everybody up on either side of one line is counterproductive. I'm a firm believer that the solutions are in the middle -- and anything that can be done to make the parties and other special interest groups weaker is a good thing.

Posted by Richard Pope

3:43 PM, Jun 12, 2008

Someone should actually organize the "G.O.P. Party" as a bona fide minor party, and run a President/V.P. ticket under that banner in the November general election. Maybe the Ron Paul people will do this, or perhaps someone can do this as a protest type of ticket. Whoever does this, gets the "G.O.P. Party" line at the top of the ballot, several hundred words for the voters pamphlets, and sets the pace for the handful of "G.O.P. Party" candidates running for lesser offices.


That way, Dino Rossi will be on record as preferring some fringe/joke "G.O.P Party" come November. That would be a lot more embarassing to Rossi, than having to associate with the semi-respectable John McCain and the at least slightly respectable Washington State Republican Party.

Posted by Independent Voice

11:38 PM, Jun 12, 2008

Democrats lie in a press release and bloggers defend them? Yuck.

They must be campaign staff...

Posted by jan

5:02 PM, Jun 13, 2008

No problem with the top two here.

However, I think it does say something about a Republican candidate if he or she decides to put GOP instead of Republican next to their name on a ballot. Same for a Democratic candidate.

Conventional wisdom is that 2008 is a bad year to run as a Republican. It looks like some Republicans are aware of that fact (there's lots of data to back the bad Republican year theory) and making a switch on the ballot.

Data also demostrates that lots of voters don't read newspapers but do read ballots and voter guides. In 2004 the state voter guide included a statement from Dino Rossi, Republican. There was no mention of the term GOP or Grand Old Party.

There's no GOP caucus in Olympia. There are two Republican caucuses. It is the Washington State Republican Party, not the GOP. Republican is a term used much more in press coverage on radio, tv, print and the web.

Consider me among the folks who consider the method a stunt, a deceipt, and a comment on the character of the candidates who do it. It's just a bad political move that will turn people off. Rossi has already suffered run-ins with truth and a tendency to evade. This won't help him.

I don't care what they put on their campaign materials. I do not like the idea of state tax dollars being used to participate in the stunt on a ballot. I'll bet Sam Reed at least wondered about the same thing.

Posted by JimD

2:16 PM, Jun 14, 2008

Rossi IS attempting to re-brand his republican association with the more editorial term, "GOP".
His reasons for doing so, and what that says about how he wants voters to view him and his candidacy, is fair game.
It's not so much about whether it will fool voters, or if that was his sole objective - which I suspect it was not.
Rather, it's about what kind of man would put lipstick on a pig for ANY reason.

Recent entries

Jul 30, 08 - 03:22 PM
Should puppies be banned?

Jul 30, 08 - 01:01 AM
Planet Obama

Jul 29, 08 - 05:55 PM
Notes on Finland

Jul 28, 08 - 01:30 AM
Obama's press

Jul 27, 08 - 12:00 AM
Summertime and the fishing is perplexing

Advertising

Marketplace

Advertising

Advertising

Categories
Calendar

July

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    
Browse the archives

July 2008

June 2008

May 2008

April 2008

March 2008

February 2008

Blogroll

Advertising

Buy a link here