Brier Dudley's Blog
Brier Dudley offers a critical look at technology and business issues affecting the Northwest.
February 11, 2008 3:00 PM
Posted by Brier Dudley
Fixing the Wi-Fi mess at Starbucks had to be one of the things on Howard Schultz's "to-do" list when he jumped back in to right the ship. I wonder if he'll be tempted to go overboard.
Apple enthusiasts are fired up because it gives them more places to get acceptable download speeds with their iPhones. Starbucks will also have the flexibility to do more content deals like its iTunes click-to-buy offering.
It's a good deal for AT&T and its customers, but this is really all about Starbucks. It's fixing a problem at the chain, pulling more customers into the stores and creating new opportunities.
I remember when the Tully's near my house began offering free Wi-Fi a year or two back. The store is across the street from a Starbucks (and three doors down from another Starbucks, and kitty-corner from Peet's and Caffe Lladro, but that's another story ...).
The Tully's manager told me sales went up about 20 percent after the store switched from paid to free Wi-Fi. But he had some issues with Starbucks customers who would carry their coffee over to his store and poach the wireless service.
Starbucks was probably getting a cut of the $6 per hour or $40 per month that T-Mobile charged for wireless in its stores, but that pricey service was driving foot traffic to other stores. The arrangement made more sense in the early days of wireless when it was more expensive to provide the service, but those times have passed. When it came time to renegotiate, it was probably hard for T-Mobile to compete with AT&T, which is hellbent on extending its data services.
Starbucks must also be looking for ways to be sure its stores still offer value when consumers cut back on spending during the downturn. First, it experiments with $1 coffees, and now free wireless. The latter makes its $4 drinks seem like a better deal, maybe even justifiable if you get some work done while you sip.
But the genius of the deal announced today is the way Starbucks is authenticating its wireless customers. To get the W-iFi, you'll have to "check in" with a Starbucks card. That gives Starbucks a big new opportunity to upsell, an opportunity that's far bigger than the iTunes deal.
In effect, the Wi-Fi becomes a storefront within a store, with a built-in transaction system.
Designer Phil Lu is getting attention online today for a mocked up Starbucks store application he designed for the iPhone. It looks great, but Lu suggested a swipe transaction system that displays a bar code on the phone screen, which you then point at a scanner. Starbucks is putting in place the components of a more elegant system, with no scanner or barcodes required.
When you fire up the laptop or mobile device, Starbucks could greet you with a welcome screen that identifies you by name if you use a credit card to load your Starbucks card. That screen can be used to offer music and other content -- maybe even to order additional beverages. You've signed on with your Starbucks card, so it knows how much credit you have, so you should be able to click to purchase and have the amount deducted from your card.
That system would be so potent, it could tempt Starbucks to interrupt your browsing with offers. There may even be ads luring you back to the Wi-Fi storefront. That seems fair during the two free hours, but it would be obnoxious for those who pay for longer usage.
AT&T broadband customers, who are getting free access at Starbucks stores under the deal, may resent commercial intrusions into a service they feel they paid for through their AT&T subscriptions.
But if Starbucks gets obnoxious with wireless come-ons, you should be able to walk across the street and find a more palatable wireless service.
Posted by Crystallin
1:09 PM, Feb 12, 2008
I admit, I've chosen Tully's over Starbucks strictly because of free wifi, even if there were Starbucks closer and I prefer their coffee drinks a little bit more.
Posted by Brier
1:38 PM, Feb 12, 2008
Maybe that's why Tully's decided not to go public ...
Posted by WineInWashington
1:54 PM, Feb 12, 2008
I prefer to go to Alki's Bakery between Starbucks and Tullys.
Free wifi- better food and support the locals.
Posted by Ed
4:05 PM, Feb 26, 2008
Totally free, commercial free wireless access is a requirement of any coffehouse I will spend time at. I'm sorry, it's too easy to find free internet these days to ever pay for it or deal with commercial interruptions. I'm sure most places just pass the cost on in their prices, of course that's more difficult when you're Starbucks already generally over-charging.
Mar 18, 08 - 12:00 AM
SourceLabs launches open-source support suite, new Linux play
Mar 17, 08 - 12:16 PM
Amazon pre-announces Microsoft's Vista SP1 ship date
Mar 17, 08 - 09:32 AM
A vision of the Web services future Microsoft is developing
Mar 14, 08 - 02:15 PM
MySpace goodies coming to WSJ, CTO says
Mar 13, 08 - 04:43 PM
Nanaimo gaga for Google
Furniture & home furnishings
AKC English Bulldog Puppies
Australian Shepherd Puppies
Firewood Seasoned - $220/cord, 2-$340, 3-$4...
POST A FREE LISTING
Share your thoughts!
Gadgets and games | Fun stuff I've written about lately includes Apple's iPhone, Hewlett-Packard's HDX laptop and Microsoft's Halo3. Also on the radar are new digital video boxes such as the Tivo HD and the Vudu.