Advertising
anchor link to jump to start of content

The Seattle Times Company NWclassifieds NWsource seattletimes.com
seattletimes.com Politics Home delivery Contact us Search archives
Your account  Today's news index  Weather  Traffic  Movies  Restaurants  Today's events
  NWCLASSIFIEDS
  NWSOURCE
  SERVICES





Behind the Curtain

July 29, 2004

Irony

Here are two pieces on what a John Kerry foreign policy would be like, one in The New Yorker, the other in The Atlantic, two liberal, Eastern Establishment magazines. They both contend Kerry's foreign policy would be a return to what is called realism, or RealPolitik, the belief that American security and interests can be best leveraged in a web of alliances, in which countries are drawn together by mutual self-interest. It's called cynical by its critics, who want to spread American democracy around the globe, by force if need be.

Bear with us, because there's a payoff of rich irony.

Here's Josh Marshall, writing in The Atlantic:

"George H.W. Bush has receded into history. But his Administration's traditional if unimaginative attitude toward foreign relations lives on through his National Security Adviser, Brent Scowcroft, who re-emerged two years ago as one of the most unabashed and difficult-to-dismiss critics of the buildup to war in Iraq. Democrats once viewed Scowcroft as the champion of an amoral and shortsighted foreign policy that sacrificed American values in order to achieve stable relations with great powers and avoid trouble in hot spots like the Balkans (a view, incidentally, shared by many of the neoconservatives who surround the current President). It was Scowcroft who secretly traveled to Beijing shortly after the Tiananmen Square massacre to reassure the Chinese that government-to-government relations needn't suffer despite the bipartisan indignation of the American public. But in 2002, lacking a consistent criticism of the drive toward war, many Democrats eagerly took shelter in Scowcroft's high-profile opposition."

After listening to Dan Feldman, a high level Kerry adviser, talk about Kerry's foreign policy, Marshall describes the conversation:

"'What you're describing to me sounds a lot like what I'd expect from Brent Scowcroft.'

'Yes,' he said. 'I think a lot of what you'd see from a Kerry Administration might be like that. I think there'd be a lot of similarities.' When I later made the same suggestion to Kerry's chief foreign-policy adviser, Rand Beers, he agreed."

In other words, Kerry is running as Bush's father -- on foreign policy, anyway.

The New Yorker story quotes Kerry as being incredulous that President Bush has ignored the foreign policy lessons of his father and Scowcroft; he then speaks of the lessons of Metternich and Henry Kissinger, two more purveyors of RealPolitik.

Another great irony here is that John Kerry got his political start testifying in front of Congress against the Vietnam War, being prosecuted at the time by Richard Nixon and his national security adviser -- Henry Kissinger.

 
Posted by J. Patrick Coolican at July 29, 2004 11:34 AM

 August 2004
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31        


 

 ARCHIVES
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004

 RECENT ENTRIES
From a home computer ...

From a Kinko's in Burlington, Vt.

Bush wants state swinging

No more Mickey Mouse for mayor

President Bush's uneviable choice

Good news for one George, bad news for another

Two housekeeping matters

President Bush in Medina

A close call for Nethercutt

Alan Keyes sweat is worth hundreds

 LINKS

Behind the curtain would like to thank Rich Meislin of The New York Times for compiling much of this list. The views expressed on the following web sites are not those of The Seattle Times, and The Seattle Times is not responsible for the content expressed on them.

The Government
The White House
The House of Representatives
GOP.gov
The Speaker's News Page
Freedom Works
House Democratic leadership page
House Clerk's Office
House Rules Committee
The Senate
Senate Republican Policy Committee
Senate Democratic Leadership
The Judiciary
Supreme Court
Federal District and Appeals Courts
Congressional Pictoral Directory
Congress.org
FedWorld Information Services
FirstGov
Federal Government Agencies
Federal Web Locator
National Governors' Association
National Conference of State Legislatures
New York State Government Information Locator

Parties & Persuasions
Democratic National Committee
Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee
Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee
New Democrats Online
Republican National Committee
National Republican Congressional Committee
National Republican Senatorial Committee
State Republican parties and candidates
Libertarian Party
Free-Market.net
Libertarian.org
Reform Party
The Green Parties worldwide
Green Party of the United States
Democratic Socialists of America
Communist Party U.S.A.
Socialist Party U.S.A.
New Party
Natural Law Party
Constitution Party
The Federalist Society
The Christian Coalition
National Right to Life Committee
National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League
Moving Ideas
People for the American Way
National Committee for an Effective Congress
Campaign for America's Future
New Democrat Networks
Democrats.com
The Interfaith Alliance
American Israel Public Affairs Committee
The Feminist Majority
American Conservative Union
Emily's List
National Organization for Women
National Rifle Association
American Civil Liberties Union
The John Birch Society
The Concord Coalition
Web Active
NetAction
AFL-CIO
MoveOn

Political Information
LA Times Electoral Vote Tracker
The American Presidency
Ballot Access News
Cato Institute
Center for Public Integrity
The Center for Voting and Democracy
Congressional Guide
Congressional Quarterly's Campaigns and Elections
Congressional roll calls
Council on Foreign Relations
Federal Election Commission
Follow the Money
Gender Gap
The Gallup Poll
Gotham Gazette
GovSpot
Heritage Foundation
InCongress
National Political Index
OpenSecrets.org
Political Information
PoliticalMoneyLine
Political Site of the Day
Political Science Resources
Politics1
Pollingreport.com
Project Vote Smart
Public Agenda
self-gov.org
TownHall.com
Voter and registration demographics
Vote.com
Whitehouse 2004

Political Media & Commentary

The Atlantic Policy & Society
C-Span
Commentary
eVote
Fast Politics
Foreign Policy
The Hill Capitol Hill news
National Review Online
The New Republic Online
Roll Call Online
Salon politics
Slate
The Weekly Standard
The Nation
Mother Jones
Arts and Letters Daily
The New York Review of Books

Public Opinion
RealClear Politics

News Organizations
ABC News
The Note
CBS News
The Los Angeles Times
The New York Times
The Wall Street Journal
The Washington Post

Foreign:
Guardian
Times Online
The Irish Times
BBC
Le Monde
Haaretz Daily
The Jerusalem Post

Locals:
The Stranger
Seattle Weekly
Seattle PI: No comment
The Tacoma New Tribune
The Oregonian
The Everett Herald
Spokesman Review
The Bremerton Sun

Private Organizations
Gallup Poll
Ipsos
Kaiser Family Foundation
MORI
Pew Research Center
PollingReport.com
Public Agenda
The Tarrance Group's Battleground Polls
Yankelovich
Zogby International

State Polls
Arkansas Poll
Field Poll
Quinnipiac University Poll
Minneapolis Star Tribune
Quinnipiac University Poll
Marist Institute for Public Opnion
Quinnipiac University Poll
Quinnipiac University Poll

Academic Organizations
Council of European Social Science Data Archives
Archives in Europe
Archives in North America
Other archives
The Eagleton Poll
General Social Survey
Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research
Odum Institute
Program on International Policy Attitudes
Racial Attitudes in America
Roper Center

Presidential Candidates
George W. Bush
John Kerry
Ralph Nader

The Blogosphere
www.talkingpointsmemo.com
www.andrewsullivan.com
Between the lines
Atrios: liberal
Kaus files
Altercation
American Prospect
Kevin Drum
Weekly standard
David Frum

The finest publication in the world:
The ONION

Powered by
Movable Type 2.51


seattletimes.com home
Home delivery | Contact us | Search archive | Site map | Low-graphic
NWclassifieds | NWsource | Advertising info | The Seattle Times Company

Copyright

Back to topBack to top